Randy Michaels: What the FCC Should Learn About AM

1

MichaelsMapBy Randy Michaels


Radioactive LLC CEO Randy Michaels says several aspects of the FCC’s recently released AM revitalization order hurt the band. In part one of this series last week, he wrote that those who wrote the order had good intentions, however making it easier for AM owners to obtain translators doesn’t really help the band. Here, Michaels points out the laws of physics that affect AMs.

Here are some things that the FCC should learn about AM radio: 1. Not even Congress can change the laws of physics, including the fact that AM stations create more interference than service.

Take this hypothetical: Let’s put a new station in the middle of Kansas with 1000 watts on 1000 kHz. The daytime .5mv/m service area would encompass 73,648 square kilometers. The .025mv/m co-channel interfering contour would encompass 467,740 square kilometers! That means the interference area is 5.3 times greater than the service area.

This is because it takes very little interfering signal to make an AM signal annoying. The FCC rules say that an undesired signal that is 1/20thof the desired signal is annoying. This number came from listening tests conducted in the 1930’s. Listeners found a 10 to one ratio annoying during musical programs, and a 30 to 1 ratio annoying during speech. So the FCC averaged these to come up with 20:1 as the d/u interference ratio. Of course most AM programming today is speech, so the situation is worse than the rules suggest.

  1. The computer programs the FCC uses are wrong. All of them — in several material respects. They are based on the “M3” conductivity map which is notoriously wrong in many areas. Most significantly, they use averages to make predictions. The f(50,50) curves mean 50% of the time and 50% of the locations. But no time is “average”. Think about it.

The average American home has 3.13 residents. So no home is average. The FCC methods used to produce coverage and interference protections use static models to reflect a dynamic environment. Propagation in the AM broadcast band is affected by temperature, foliage, sunspots, the 11 year solar cycle, the water tables, and many other variables.

Even when the map averages are right, individual days and times of the day are quite different.

Received AM signals can be three times stronger on cold winter days than hot summer days, which is why measurements taken to support new stations are so often made in August. Well and good, but those stations then operate all winter!

The FCC has used all sorts of illogical thinking to cram in more stations. The use of static models to show a dynamic environment is one of them. If a new station can be added or a current station modified so as not to raise the allocation limits as depicted by the computer models then it’s approved. But when many stations operate on the same channel, what are the odds that the path from one of them to the target station is above average on a given night? 50/50!

Listeners in the Midwest who pay attention will notice that some nights the New York stations come booming in, but Chicago is weak. Other nights Chicago is crowding neighboring N.Y. stations off the dial. Other times, it’s the Southern stations that come in best. Some path is likely to be above average on any given night!

  1. The Critical Hours problem. “AM improvement” is to be accomplished in part by relaxing restrictions of Critical Hours operation. The problem is that Critical Hours effects are quite real and have been ignored to the detriment of many current stations.

For instance, when the FCC decided to allow regional channels up to 50kw, one of the stations that got increased power was WHBC Canton, from 5kw to 15kw daytime. The computer programs show that this power level protects co-channel WDJO Cincinnati and it does, at noon. Many fall afternoons, WHBC can be heard overriding WDJO in downtown Cincinnati, sometimes as early as 3p.m. I get about 12mv/m on WDJO at my house.

Remember that the “protected” day contour is .5mv/m. WDJO gets wiped out by WHBC many fall and winter mornings and afternoons. Critical Hours interference is real, and destroys both drive times for many stations. Another example is 1360 in San Diego which uses a tall, centrally located tower and has, on paper, a low night limit. As KGB, this frequency was long a market leader. The 50kw operation of a station in Glendale, AZ destroys 1360 inside the San Diego city limits some afternoons. I’m not suggesting that WHBC or KPXQ Glendale operate illegally, just that the FCC has turned a blind eye to how stations actually propagate.

Shown with this story is a map of the day service and interfering contour of a hypothetical station operating at 1kw and 1000 kHz in the middle of Kansas.

Next time, Michaels will discuss what the FCC can do to help AM stations.

You do not have permission to view the comments.