Accessible emergency information requirements are at the heart of a waiver extension request that has been made alongside a Petition for Rulemaking submitted by the NAB with the FCC’s Media Bureau, an action designed to clarify rules pertaining to aural representations of visual, non-textual content such as radar maps and other graphics on a secondary audio channel.
The rule dates to the Wheeler Commission; a compliance date of May 26, 2015 was originally put into place for a rule that requires broadcasters to offer an audio interpretation of what would normally be a video image without verbal commentary. The goal: to bring sight-impaired consumers every detail those with vision can attain in the event of an emergency.
Naturally, questions abound with regard to the “how” behind this rule, and the NAB’s petition wants the Commission to amend the rule so that compliance is met if a broadcast TV station provides textual crawls that convey emergency information duplicative of or equivalent to the visual, non-textual information.
Section 79.2(b)(2)(ii) of the Commission’s rules requires video programming providers to ensure that emergency information provided visually during non-newscast programming is made accessible to individuals who are blind or visually impaired through the use of a secondary audio stream to provide such information aurally.
Here’s where the trouble comes for television stations: the FCC rule states that the aural description of this information must accurately and effectively convey the critical details regarding the emergency and how to respond to the emergency. What does this mean, with respect to aural interpretation?
In the West Palm Beach market, Hearst Television’s WPBF-25 regularly offers picture-in-picture severe weather alerts during early-fringe programming such as “Jeopardy” and “Wheel of Fortune.” Does this make WPBF and Hearst responsible for an audio description of radar? How does it accomplish this, short of simulcasting an automated NOAA weather channel?
While those questions remain after nearly decade, the NAB petition could set up a test — does a crawl meet a rule designed to those who are blind? Clearly, some groups might find the NAB petition problematic. However, with the Carr Commission coming in weeks, along with a “light-touch” regulatory philosophy championed by former Chairman Ajit Pai, the rule itself could be targeted in the coming months as one to simply eliminate.
At issue for the NAB is the technology behind accurate live audio interpretations of non-textual emergency information. It’s been nearly impossible to accomplish over the nine-plus years the rule has been in place, it says, and a waiver is in place that allows broadcasters to avoid rule non-compliance. The NAB wants a fourth 18-month extension of this waiver, pending resolution to the rulemaking petition. The current waiver expires today (11/26); without a waiver, the NAB warns that TV stations could simply cease providing visual but non-textual emergency information due to compliance concerns.
The association asserts that a technical solution for compliance remains elusive. But, it is committed to ensuring that sight-impaired consumers aren’t left in the dark. The NAB says it has shared a draft best practices documents with advocates for individuals who are blind or visually impaired and “looks forward to incorporating their input in the final product.”
Should the petition move forward? The Media Bureau is seeking comment, and interested parties have until December 26 to submit them with the Commission. The NAB’s reply comment deadline is January 9, 2025, ensuring the Rosenworcel Commission has the opportunity to consider the petition from Chief Legal Officer Rick Kaplan.



