NAB Hits Back at EAS Vendor in Fight Over Software Flexibility

0

The NAB is continuing its push for the Federal Communications Commission to formally open a rulemaking that would allow broadcast stations to adopt software-based Emergency Alert System technology, replacing the longstanding requirement for physical hardware devices.


The group’s proposal, backed by a wide swath of the broadcast and cable industry, argues it’s time to retire the “one-box-fits-all” mandate and bring EAS into the 21st century. But one key vendor isn’t ready to let go of the box just yet.

In reply comments submitted this week, Rick Kaplan, Larry Walke, Kelly Williams, and David Layer emphasized the urgent need for regulatory flexibility on behalf of the NAB. The group’s proposal, originally filed in March, asks the Commission to amend Part 11 of its rules to give EAS participants the option to process alerts using virtual encoders and decoders (ENDECs), rather than the dedicated rack-mounted boxes currently mandated.

NAB noted its petition drew “nearly unanimous support” from commercial and noncommercial broadcasters, cable operators, engineers, manufacturers, and Sage Alerting Systems, one of only two primary suppliers of EAS hardware, “With only one self-interested detractor.”

Sage, which announced it would cease production of its ENDEC hardware due to legacy part supply constraints, wrote that “the time for a software-only option has come.” Joint comments from public broadcasters described the proposal as a way to improve “EAS continuity, security, flexibility, and agility.”

Supporters said transitioning to software-based systems could shorten recovery time in the event of failure, reduce downtime through instant failover, accelerate security patches, and eliminate the need to physically ship or repair hardware.

“The NAB’s proposal will improve EAS continuity, security, flexibility, and agility,” wrote the Joint Public Radio Broadcasters, which include New York Public Radio and University Radio Foundation.

So what about the one remaining major manufacturer of dedicated EAS devices?

Despite this consensus, Digital Alert Systems opposed the petition, submitting 46 pages of comments that raised a wide range of concerns about certification, compliance, and cybersecurity. NAB pushed back, characterizing DAS’s objections as obstructionist and self-interested.

“DAS’s doomsday warnings against a software-based EAS option should be taken with a large grain of salt,” NAB wrote. “DAS’s self-interest is even more pronounced when compared to Sage’s willingness to tackle the technical challenges that NAB’s proposal may raise.”

NAB also noted it first approached both Sage and DAS in 2021 to discuss the idea, but only Sage “engaged constructively.”

“Trying to present the FCC with a fully-baked, bulletproof Petition for Rulemaking that anticipates and answers every conceivable question DAS can conjure up would only delay progress even more, and perhaps indefinitely, which may well be DAS’s goal,” NAB wrote.

The organization clarified that the proposal would not mandate software use, but rather provide a voluntary alternative. “Stations would no longer have to ‘locate, schedule, and deploy a contract engineer to physically diagnose and repair’ a device,” the filing said, quoting the Society of Broadcast Engineers.

Sage added that stations could “continue using a dedicated physical device, or use mixed-purpose hardware, or run EAS software on a personal computer or server.”

NAB concluded: “EAS is the last link in modern broadcast air chains that remains stuck in a hardware world. NAB submits that it is long past time for the Commission to allow EAS to similarly evolve into a software-based environment.”