WASHINGTON, D.C. — The FCC’s Media Bureau has established a comment cycle in which interested parties can chime in on a Petition for Rulemaking from XGN/X1 Mobile and Tyche Media that seeks Commission approval for low-power television stations to use the 5G Broadcast transmission standard on a voluntary basis.
XGN/X1 and Tyche, which operates experimental 5G Broadcast station WCRN-LD on Channel 30 in Boston, believe 5G Broadcast can serve as a worthy alternative to the currently authorized ATSC 1.0 and ATSC 3.0 transmission standards. As such, they want the 5G Broadcast standard to be incorporated into the Commission’s rules and authorized for deployment.
It would be up to low-power TV stations to decide whether or not to go that route, and not spending the dollars needed to go to ATSC 3.0 — a costly proposition for some low-power and TV translator station owners.
Whether or not the incorporation of the 5G Broadcast standard into the Commission rules is necessary is the subject of industry debate. The Advanced Television Broadcast Alliance, in its member newsletter, earlier this week responded to the XGN/X1 and Tyche Media petition, filed with the Commission on August 10.
“What the Commission would actually be deciding is whether a broadcast license may carry a transmission standard developed for and governed by the cellular industry,” ATVA Executive Director Lee Miller believes. “That holding is portable. The free-stream requirement, the 2 MHz public safety floor, the mandatory-carriage carve-out — all of that is a condition on the grant, and conditions get revisited, waived, and narrowed in later proceedings by parties who were not in this one.”
Miller continues, “The television band is allocated and licensed for broadcasting under the Commission’s rules and its allocation table. The broadcast waveform running on it reinforces that identity rather than creating it. But identity in spectrum policy is argued, not declared, and the standard authorized on a band is the strongest evidence anyone brings to that argument. That is the load-bearing fact behind the protections LPTV has. Ordinary Part 74 LPTV and translator stations are secondary, and their displacement rules assume the band exists to deliver a licensed local service. Class A stations sit in a separate category with primary status under their own framework. Different footing, same premise underneath.”
He then notes that ATBA members “do not evaluate a spectrum proposal only on its engineering. They evaluate it on what it makes possible for someone else, later. An operator who lost a channel in the repack does not need to be told that a technically reasonable proceeding can end badly for secondary licensees. They have the paperwork.”
While the ATBA “has no objection to 5G Broadcast as a delivery method,” the organization objections to establishing it as a separate regulatory standard “when the capability already exists inside ATSC 3.0, the broadcaster-controlled digital television standard sold at retail as NextGen TV.”
For Miller, “The standards work is finished. ATSC completed it as an amendment to Recommended Practice A/327, which is a recommended practice rather than a mandatory transmission standard. It describes how ATSC 3.0 and a second system, including LTE-based 5G Broadcast, can share a single television channel through time-domain multiplexing. We also support finishing the ATSC 3.0 transition on a definite schedule. LPTV does not need simulcast relief to move. What our members need is timing certainty, including when Class A stations get relief from the simulcast obligation in Section 73.6029.”
For those interested in submitting comments in what is MB Docket No. 26-263, comments are due on October 19. The reply comment date is November 18.



